How to Pick the Right Fitting Method?

How to Pick the Right Fitting Method? When to Opt for Press Fits?

If you have children or have had exposure to young learners, you may recognize a variant of the pound-a-peg toy depicted in the image below. In this activity, a toddler engages by inserting a peg into one of the designated apertures and subsequently employing a hammer to drive it into place. The tapered pegs halt upon achieving a press or interference fit through the application of adequate force.

One may ponder whether this toy primarily serves to cultivate hand-eye coordination or if it forms part of a broader initiative aimed at acquainting children with fundamental mechanical principles, thereby fostering an interest in STEM disciplines. I leave it to your discretion to discern the underlying purpose, although I personally harbor a vested interest in facilitating my toddler’s development through such activities.

Irrespective of the intended educational objective, the introduction of press-fit toys to children serves as a rudimentary illustration of how engineers strategize mechanical assemblies. Press fits offer versatility in accommodating diverse scenarios, facilitating component alignment, and establishing enduring connections between constituent parts.

How to Pick the Right Fitting Method? When to Opt for Press Fits?插图


However, press fits may not be universally suitable for all applications, as there exist both advantages and disadvantages associated with interference fits (refer to the section on slip fits in this article). Therefore, it is essential to understand the key considerations of press fits and evaluate their appropriateness for your specific application. Further insights on this topic can be found in the subsequent sections of this article.

Additionally, it’s worth noting that press fits represent just one option among various mechanical assembly methods available for your designs. For an extensive exploration of diverse mechanical fastening techniques, I recommend consulting our comprehensive guide titled “From Snap Fits to Adhesives: A Comprehensive Guide to Mechanical Fastener Options.

Exercise Caution When Employing Press Fits in Plastic Components

Prudence is advised when utilizing press fits with plastic components. Why? The phenomenon known as cold creep warrants attention. Cold creep, also referred to as cold flow, denotes the gradual and permanent deformation experienced by a solid material subjected to prolonged stress below its yield stress.

How to Pick the Right Fitting Method? When to Opt for Press Fits?插图1

Dowel and hole fits for plastic components operate under constant stress and friction mechanisms. While materials like steel can endure constant tensile loads without faltering, plastics exhibit susceptibility to creep under extended tensile loading conditions. Consequently, plastic is not an optimal choice for press fits due to its lower strength, flexibility, low melting point, amorphous (non-crystalline) structure, and weak intermolecular forces.

While an interference fit may suffice for assemblies involving both plastic and metal components (e.g., a metal shaft inserted into a plastic hub), an alternative to consider for joining two plastic pieces is a snap-fit. For further insights, our snap-fit design guide offers valuable information.

Analyzing Force Dynamics in Interference Fits

Having explored the pitfalls of utilizing press fits indiscriminately, it is imperative to delve into their judicious application. Press fits operate on the principles of enduring stress and friction, succinctly put, the assembly hinges upon the interplay of two components vying for spatial occupancy. However, determining the optimal level of interference for a given application warrants careful consideration.

Consider the analogy of donning a pair of jeans: a snug fit is desirable, yet excessive tightness jeopardizes the feasibility of wear.

How to Pick the Right Fitting Method? When to Opt for Press Fits?插图2

Determining the optimal interference fit for precise assembly is facilitated by leveraging dowel pins as an illustrative example, particularly considering the excessive machining costs associated with alternative press fits. Consultation of established reference tables is recommended for interference determination, albeit allowances for certain variations may apply. Paramount among considerations is the efficacy of the interference in ensuring the integrity of the assembled components within the design framework.

How to Pick the Right Fitting Method? When to Opt for Press Fits?插图3

One approach is to initiate the evaluation by analyzing the elastic deformation. Upon insertion of the pin into the hole, it exerts radial pressure outward, endeavoring to restore its original diameter. Concurrently, the hole applies radial pressure inward, also endeavoring to regain its original dimensions. The interaction of these two components generates a normal force, which, in conjunction with the friction coefficient, facilitates the determination of the resultant grip. This constitutes the fundamental principle underlying a press fit design.

Consider, for instance, a scenario involving a steel dowel pin being pressed into a steel plate with a designated nominal half-inch diameter and a depth of one inch. It is pertinent to note the term “nominal” here, denoting that the pin is marginally larger and the hole marginally smaller, thus qualifying as nominal—half-inch in nomenclature only. A standard series half-inch pin typically measures 0.5002 inches in diameter, exceeding the nominal size by two ten-thousandths. With a recommended minimum press fit hole diameter of 0.4995 inches, an interference of 0.0007 inches in diameter ensues. Although seemingly minute, the ensuing discussion will underscore its considerable significance.

How to Pick the Right Fitting Method? When to Opt for Press Fits?插图4
How to Pick the Right Fitting Method? When to Opt for Press Fits?插图5

For instance, in the case of a half-inch pin, with Young’s modulus of 210 GPa, Poisson’s ratio of 0.292, a contact area (A) of 1013.415 mm2, and a friction coefficient of 0.30, the resultant axial force is approximately 45kN — roughly equivalent to the weight of a Ford F350.

In contrast, a half-inch bolt can withstand more than twice that force. Nonetheless, when employing a bolt, a hole can be drilled with a diameter tolerance of 0.020 inches. Conversely, in a press fit scenario, a deviation of just 0.0007 inches in the hole diameter could result in no interference, underscoring the criticality of precise press fit tolerances.

Refined Terminology for Tolerances and Alignment Restrictions:

Precision Requirements and Assembly Considerations It’s evident that even minor interferences can result in significant forces. The axial retention force not only ensures part cohesion but also dictates assembly requirements. Hence, meticulous attention is crucial when specifying press fits to prevent potential damage to the hydraulic press utilized for assembly. This stringent machining tolerance underscores the rationale for steering clear of press fits in conventional industrial assembly processes, as they are not conducive to Design for Manufacturability/Assembly (DFM/DFA) principles.

Our complimentary press fit calculator facilitates the determination of minimum retention force and maximum assembly force across various diametrical tolerances. However, it’s essential to note that diameter isn’t the sole tolerance consideration; the spacing between pins, especially when employed in pairs, warrants careful consideration.

Access our Press Fit Calculator

A cardinal rule in press fit applications is limiting each assembly operation to no more than two pins. Opting for a single interference fit coupled with a slip-fit secondary pin for alignment presents a superior alternative. In instances where two press-fit pins are necessary, employing Geometric Dimensioning and Tolerancing (GD&T) ensures optimal alignment, with the first hole serving as the datum for the second, thereby minimizing discrepancies between the two features.

How to Pick the Right Fitting Method? When to Opt for Press Fits?插图6

Materials and Thermal Behavior in Press Fit Interfaces

In line with the principles of thermodynamics, specifically the Third Law, it is established that the entropy of a system asymptotically approaches a constant value as temperature decreases towards absolute zero, wherein entropy reaches zero. Consequently, thermal expansion tendencies diminish with decreasing temperatures.

Conversely, it is widely acknowledged that most materials exhibit contraction with decreasing temperatures, albeit not uniformly. The extent of this contraction or expansion is quantified by the coefficient of thermal expansion unique to each material. It is imperative to consider this parameter meticulously in the design of press fits, ensuring compatibility by employing materials with closely aligned coefficients of thermal expansion.

How to Pick the Right Fitting Method? When to Opt for Press Fits?插图7

Considering a scenario where a one-inch nominal aluminum pin is utilized within a hole on a 410 stainless steel component with a diametrical interference of 0.0007 inches, the inquiry arises as to the threshold temperature at which the shrinkage effect nullifies the interference.

Upon examination of the coefficients of linear expansion inherent in the respective materials, it becomes evident that for every degree Fahrenheit decrease in temperature, the CNC-machined aluminum experiences a contraction of approximately 0.0000125 in/in, whereas the stainless steel contracts by approximately 0.0000055 in/in, less than half the contraction rate of aluminum. If the assembly is initially conducted at 75 degrees Fahrenheit and subsequently exposed to a temperature of minus 25 degrees Fahrenheit, the integrity of the press fit connection will be compromised entirely due to thermal contraction.

For a comprehensive assessment of the linear thermal expansion pertinent to your proposed press fit interface, referencing “The Bimetallic Strip Explained” can provide valuable insights.

Optimizing Joint Configurations: Overconstraint and Alternative Approaches

Press fits offer a dual function of both locating and joining components, presenting a unique advantage in assembly processes. However, this integrated functionality can introduce complexities, as precision and strength requirements become interdependent. Achieving the necessary accuracy and robustness may entail meticulous dimensioning, often down to minute tolerances, which can pose challenges for manufacturing.

Yet, in acknowledging the limitations of press fits, there exists a spectrum of alternative joint configurations that offer distinct advantages. A strategic shift towards alternative approaches can untangle the intertwined demands of precision and strength, thereby alleviating the burdens associated with overconstraint.

One such approach involves adopting slip-fit dowel pins for self-locating purposes, while employing bolts for the joining function. This separation of tasks allows for a more nuanced control over accuracy and robustness, facilitating streamlined manufacturing processes.

In the realm of plastic component assembly, employing locating pins for alignment and snap fits for assembly presents another effective alternative. By leveraging these methods, designers can tailor joint configurations to suit specific material properties and assembly requirements, thereby expanding the toolkit for mechanical assembly solutions.

In essence, the realm of alternative joint design offers a rich tapestry of possibilities, enabling engineers to navigate the complexities of assembly with greater flexibility and precision. By embracing these alternatives, manufacturers can transcend the constraints of traditional press fits, unlocking new avenues for innovation and optimization in mechanical assembly.

How to Pick the Right Fitting Method? When to Opt for Press Fits?插图8

Optimal Implementation of Press Fits in Design

While press fits can be advantageous in certain scenarios—particularly for machined components of similar materials with stringent tolerances necessitating precise alignment—an interference fit may not always be the optimal choice for your assembly. It is prudent to explore alternative methodologies. Should inquiries arise from management regarding the decision against utilizing press fits, you are now equipped with a comprehensive response.

BOYI – Streamlining Procurement Processes

BOYI serves as your integrated platform for bespoke manufacturing, facilitating expedited, simplified, and more effective part acquisition. In essence, BOYI empowers engineers like yourself to focus on engineering tasks, rather than expending time and effort on sourcing, assessing, onboarding, and managing suppliers.

Through BOYI, numerous enterprises have optimized their workflows for custom part procurement, thereby unlocking potential for innovation in product development and revolutionizing the approach to designing, refining, and delivering the next wave of products. Register an account today and upload your component to experience firsthand the benefits of our instantaneous online CNC quoting system, comprehensive design for manufacturability insights, and intuitive platform functionalities tailored to your needs.

FAQs

Q1: What is friction fitting?

A1: Friction fitting is a method where two parts are joined by the friction between them, often without additional fasteners or adhesives. It relies on a tight fit between mating surfaces to create a secure connection.

Q2: What is a press fit?

A2: A press fit is a type of interference fit where one part is inserted tightly into another part, creating a secure and rigid connection without the need for fasteners or adhesives.

Q3: Do you have a press fit tolerance calculator?

A3: Yes, we offer a press fit tolerance calculator that helps determine the appropriate tolerances for press fit assemblies based on the dimensions and materials of the components involved.

Q4: How does the press fit calculator work?

A4: The press fit calculator evaluates the interference between mating parts and suggests suitable tolerances to achieve the desired press fit, ensuring a snug and reliable connection.

Q5: What is a slip fit tolerance?

A5: A slip fit tolerance refers to the allowance between mating parts, where one part can easily slide or slip into the other with minimal interference, providing a looser connection compared to a press fit.

Q6: What is a fit pin?

A6: A fit pin is a precision component used to align and secure two or more parts in a mechanical assembly, typically through press fitting or interference fitting.

Q7: How do you achieve a dowel pin press fit?

A7: A dowel pin press fit is achieved by tightly inserting a dowel pin into a corresponding hole in another part, ensuring precise alignment and stability in the assembly.

Q8: Is hand pressing against glass recommended for assembly?

A8: Hand pressing against glass is not recommended for assembly purposes as it can lead to uneven pressure distribution and potential breakage or damage to the glass.

Q9: What’s the difference between “tight” and “fit” in assembly terminology?

A9: “Tight” typically refers to a secure and snug fit between mating parts, while “fit” denotes the compatibility and suitability of components for assembly.

Q10: What is a press fit pin?

A10: A press fit pin is a type of fastener or alignment component that is inserted tightly into a hole or receptacle, creating a secure and rigid connection without the need for additional fasteners.

Q11: Do you offer an interference fit calculator?

A11: Yes, our interference fit calculator helps determine the appropriate tolerances for interference fit assemblies, ensuring proper alignment and secure connections.

Q12: What is a slip fit?

A12: A slip fit is a type of assembly where one part easily slides or slips into another part with minimal interference, allowing for easy insertion and removal without the need for excessive force.

Q13: What tolerance is suitable for a slip fit?

A13: The tolerance for a slip fit depends on the specific requirements of the assembly but typically allows for a small clearance between mating parts to facilitate easy insertion and removal.

Q14: What does “cool cool cool tight tight tight” signify in assembly terminology?

A14: “Cool cool cool tight tight tight” is a colloquial expression emphasizing the need for precision and snugness in assembly, ensuring a secure and reliable connection between mating parts.

Leave a Reply